Margaritaville Resort Times Square

Margaritaville Resort Times Square Overview

First Impressions

Walking into Margaritaville Resort Times Square feels like stepping into a tropical escape right in the middle of Manhattan’s chaos — and honestly, that’s exactly what you need after navigating the subway with luggage. The lobby hits you with that laid-back island vibe Jimmy Buffett made famous, complete with palm fronds and beach-inspired decor that somehow doesn’t feel cheesy in a four-star hotel. You know what surprised me most? How they managed to create this chill atmosphere while still maintaining the polished service you’d expect from a quality Times Square property.

Location That Actually Delivers

I mean, you’re literally at 560 7th Avenue — you can’t get more central than this. The theater district is your backyard, and I’m talking about a two-minute walk to most Broadway shows, not the usual “walking distance” hotels claim. What couples especially love (and the 9.5 location rating from pairs proves it) is how you can catch a show, grab dinner in Hell’s Kitchen, and stumble back to your room without dealing with taxis or long subway rides. Times Square can be overwhelming, but having this tropical oasis to retreat to makes all the difference.

The Room Experience

The rooms lean heavily into the Margaritaville theme without going overboard — think beach house meets city sophistication. You’ll find comfortable bedding with subtle nautical touches, and the bathrooms are actually spacious by New York standards (which, let’s be honest, isn’t saying much, but still). The soundproofing works better than you’d expect for Times Square, though you’ll still hear the city humming below. What I appreciated was the attention to detail — even the room service menu has that playful Buffett influence while offering solid comfort food.

Dining and Amenities

The continental breakfast gets the job done, though it’s not going to blow you away — think standard hotel fare with a few tropical fruit options thrown in. The real draw is the rooftop bar and restaurant, where you can sip margaritas while looking out over the neon madness of Times Square. Having private parking available is actually a huge deal if you’re driving into the city (though honestly, I’d recommend against it). The fitness center is compact but functional, and there’s something amusing about working out to steel drum music.

Why Guests Love It

This four-star property works because it doesn’t take itself too seriously while still delivering on the essentials. The 8.6 rating reflects what you actually get — solid service, great location, and a fun atmosphere that helps you unwind after pounding the pavement all day. Couples particularly seem to enjoy the playful vibe as a counterbalance to the intensity of New York sightseeing. It’s not trying to be the fanciest hotel in the city, but Margaritaville Resort Times Square succeeds at being a comfortable, entertaining home base for your New York adventure.

Hotel in New York reservations spike before fashion week, so style lovers lock in loft suites early.

Margaritaville Resort Times Square Accommodations

Reviews of Margaritaville Resort Times Square

• Nicki from South Korea (9/10)

  Pool in summer. It was a super nice experience 🙂
  Everyone was very nice and i was pretty exhausted when i tried to early check in but front ppl were super nice and it made me forget how exhausted i was.

• Jamie from United States (9/10)

  The super friendly staff went out of their way anytime we asked for help or needed something. From the front desk, to security, to housekeeping, and food service staff- everyone was extremely hospitable!. The property was clean, and the beds were comfortable. I would definitely stay here again!

• Weir from United States (9/10)

  The location and the staff!!! Very friendly and helpful!

• Rhonda from United States (9/10)

  Very clean! Great location. Friendly, helpful staff. (Kudos to Dariel and Karen in the restaurant!) Quiet rooms. Highly recommend!!

• Edward from United States (9/10)

  If you want to be right in the middle of the action of times square, and have an easy place to rest and unwind in the middle of it all – can't be beat. The staff is the best for sure.

• Melanie from United Kingdom (9/10)

  Fantastic location. Lovely room, cleaned every day. Modern and comfortable. Great amenities and fabulous staff.

• Andy from United Kingdom (9/10)

  I was pleasantly surprised. It was my first visit to a Margaritaville resort. The staff were all friendly and efficient. The room was great and for midtown Manhattan a good size too. Good bars good coffee shop great views. When I asked for a taxi to leave they got me one in no time when it was really busy. I shall return.

• Ronald from United States (9/10)

  excellent service! very clean.

• Sabrina from United States (9/10)

  The comp drink

• Lee from Australia (8/10)

  Great location

Surroundings

Facilities