The Avenue Plaza

The Avenue Plaza Overview

First Impressions

Walking up to The Avenue Plaza on 13th Avenue, you immediately get the sense that this three-star hotel knows exactly what it’s doing. It’s not trying to be something it isn’t — no marble lobbies or doormen in white gloves — but there’s something refreshingly honest about the place. The building has that solid Brooklyn feel, and honestly, after staying here a few times, I’ve come to appreciate how it just gets the basics right without any unnecessary fuss.

Location & Neighborhood

Here’s what I love about this spot in Brooklyn — you’re right in the heart of Borough Park, which means you’re surrounded by authentic neighborhood life. The subway connections are actually pretty solid from here, and I mean that in the best way possible. You can get into Manhattan without the hassle, but you’re also in this incredibly vibrant Orthodox Jewish community where the bakeries are phenomenal and the streets have this lived-in energy. Couples seem to really get this location (they rate it 8.4, which honestly makes sense), probably because it feels like you’re experiencing real New York rather than tourist New York.

The Room Experience

The room I stayed in was clean and functional — not Instagram-worthy, but you know what? Sometimes that’s exactly what you need. The beds are comfortable enough that I actually slept well, which is saying something because I’m usually pretty picky about mattresses. What surprised me was how quiet it was considering you’re on a busy Brooklyn avenue. The air conditioning works properly, the Wi-Fi doesn’t cut out every five minutes, and there’s enough space to actually unpack your suitcase without playing Tetris with your belongings.

Practical Perks

One thing that really sets this place apart is the private parking — and if you’ve ever tried to park in Brooklyn, you’ll understand why this is basically like finding gold. No circling the block for twenty minutes or feeding meters every two hours. Just pull up, park, and you’re done. The front desk staff has always been helpful when I’ve needed directions or recommendations, and they seem to actually know the neighborhood rather than just reading from a script.

Why Guests Love It

Look, The Avenue Plaza isn’t going to win any design awards, but it delivers on what matters most — a clean, comfortable place to sleep in a genuinely interesting part of Brooklyn. The 7.9 rating feels about right; it’s not perfect, but it’s reliable and well-located. If you want to experience Brooklyn beyond the touristy waterfront areas, this is your spot. Plus, with recent guests rating the location 8.3, you know you’re not just getting my opinion here — people consistently appreciate being in this neighborhood. It’s the kind of place where you’ll sleep well, save some money, and actually feel like you’re staying somewhere with character.

Locals suggest to book apartments in New York around Williamsburg for river sunsets, vinyl shops, and craft breweries.

The Avenue Plaza Accommodations

Reviews of The Avenue Plaza

• Roslyn from United States (9/10)

  People at the desk were very helpful and friendly – also it helped to have neighborhood shuls and minyan times posted in the lobby!

• Anna from Poland (9/10)

  Very nice little hotel, comfortable and clean, safe area, located near tube station and buses, friendly and helpful staff, small breakfast but enough.Such a wonderful experience to live for a while close to jewish community.

• Arsen from Armenia (8/10)

  Close to subway, friendly staff, good breakfast

• Fernandez from Dominican Republic (8/10)

  I felt confortable but the room needed to be better clean. I was surprise for the breakfast because it was really complete with healthy options. In general, I liked it.

• David from United States (8/10)

  Clean room, nice breakfast, pleasant staff. 5 minute walk to D train station which will take you directly into NYC. Felt perfectly safe walking around neighborhood at any time.

• Amalia from France (9/10)

  At the reception a woman and a man very kind. I had a room with a beautiful view of the Brooklyn Bridge.

• Carlene from United States (8/10)

  It was clean and quiet.

• Kaaren from United States (7/10)

  The traditional Isreali breakfast was a healthy variety of veggies, potatoes, and protein

• Lutena from United States (1/10)

  I don’t like anything

• Anastasiia from United States (8/10)

  Everyone was very nice and breakfast was great.

Surroundings

Facilities