Fitzpatrick Manhattan

Fitzpatrick Manhattan Overview

You know what struck me first about the Fitzpatrick Manhattan? Walking into the lobby actually feels like stepping into someone’s well-appointed Irish townhouse rather than another generic Midtown hotel. There’s this genuine warmth to the place that’s honestly refreshing when you’re dealing with the usual New York hustle. The staff – and I mean this – actually remember your name after the first day, which is sort of rare around here.

The location on Lexington is pretty stellar if you ask me. You’re right in that sweet spot of Midtown East where you can walk to Grand Central in about eight minutes (I timed it), but you’re far enough from the Times Square chaos that you can actually think straight. What I really appreciate is being so close to the 6 train at 59th – makes getting around the city way easier than dealing with some of the tourist-heavy stations. Plus, there’s this great little deli right around the corner on 58th that locals actually use, not just another overpriced tourist trap.

The rooms themselves have this Irish boutique hotel vibe that actually works. I mean, it could’ve been cheesy, but they pulled it off with these rich fabrics and dark wood furniture that feels substantial, you know? The beds are honestly fantastic – firm but not rock-hard – and the soundproofing is better than you’d expect for Midtown (though you’ll still hear some street noise if you’re facing Lexington). What really got me was the attention to small details: proper hangers in the closet, outlets where you actually need them, and a bathroom that doesn’t feel like an afterthought. The shower pressure is solid, which honestly makes or breaks a hotel stay for me.

Their Fitz & Follies restaurant downstairs serves proper Irish comfort food, and while it’s not going to revolutionize your dining experience, the fish and chips are legit and the Guinness is poured right. Perfect for those nights when you just want something hearty without venturing back out into the city. The bar gets busy with both hotel guests and locals during happy hour – actually a good sign in my book.

Here’s the thing though – this isn’t the cheapest option in the area, and if you’re looking for ultra-modern amenities or a flashy scene, you might feel underwhelmed. But if you want a place that feels like it has some personality, where the staff treats you like a person instead of a room number, and you can walk to most of what you need in Midtown, it’s honestly a solid choice. I’ve stayed here three times now, and each time I leave thinking it’s one of those places that just gets hospitality right without trying too hard.

Fitzpatrick Manhattan Accommodations

Reviews of Fitzpatrick Manhattan

• Scott from United States (9/10)

  The hotel could use a refresh.
  Perfect location, perfect size property
  Great Value
  Terrific staff

• Sharon from Ireland (9/10)

  Highly recommend Fitzpatrick Manhattan, excellent location and staff are so friendly and helpful. A big shout out to Brendan from Carlow 👏Great musicians there on a Friday evening, my husband was delighted to sing a song with them

• Ollie from Ireland (8/10)

  Staff, location,

• Eileen from United States (8/10)

  Good food. A little expensive but tasty.

• Joe from United States (8/10)

  Nice, roomy suite.

• Paul from Ireland (8/10)

  Its location

• Leo from Ireland (7/10)

  Very comfortable bed and pillows

• Liz from Australia (9/10)

  Location
  Friendly staff

• John from United States (7/10)

  Very friendly staff in a great location. The room was very clean.

• Srobona from United States (9/10)

  Friendly, casual, wecoming staff. Nicely kept up historic building. Reasonable prices for NYC. The suite is a lot of room—surprisingly spacious

Surroundings

Facilities