A and FayeBed and Breakfast, Inc,

A and FayeBed and Breakfast, Inc, Overview

First Impressions

Walking up to A and FayeBed and Breakfast, Inc on Marlborough Road, you immediately get that \”hidden gem\” feeling. This three-star bed and breakfast sits quietly in a residential Brooklyn neighborhood that honestly feels more like a peaceful suburb than the bustling borough most people picture. The Victorian-style house has this welcoming front porch that makes you want to sit with a cup of coffee — which, as it turns out, you’ll definitely want to do after experiencing their breakfast.

Location & Neighborhood

Here’s what I love about this spot in Brooklyn — you’re in Flatbush, which means you get authentic neighborhood vibes without feeling disconnected from the city. The tree-lined streets are perfect for morning walks, and there’s something really charming about staying somewhere that locals actually call home. Couples seem to particularly appreciate the quieter atmosphere (they consistently rate the location around 8.8), and I can see why. You’re close enough to hop on the subway when you want Manhattan energy, but far enough away to actually sleep well at night.

The Room Experience

The room I stayed in had that perfect bed-and-breakfast balance — homey without being cluttered, comfortable without trying too hard to be fancy. You know what really impressed me? The attention to small details that make a difference when you’re traveling. Good lighting for reading, enough outlets for your devices, and — this might sound minor — but the curtains actually block out light when you want to sleep in. The whole place feels like staying at a well-organized friend’s house, if that friend happened to be really good at hospitality.

Breakfast & Morning Routine

Okay, so the breakfast situation here is actually worth planning your morning around. They do both Continental and American options, which means you can go light with pastries and coffee or commit to the full eggs-and-bacon experience. I mean, when you’re staying at a bed and breakfast, the breakfast part better be good, right? What struck me was how they manage to make it feel personal even when there are other guests around. The dining area has this communal-but-not-awkward vibe where you might chat with other travelers or just enjoy your meal in peace.

Why Guests Love It

With a 9.3 rating, this place is clearly doing something right, and after staying here, I think it comes down to authenticity. A and FayeBed and Breakfast, Inc doesn’t try to be something it’s not — it’s a genuine neighborhood bed and breakfast run by people who actually care about your experience. The location gets consistently high marks because it offers that rare combination of local character and practical access to the rest of the city. Plus, there’s something refreshing about staying somewhere that feels like a real part of Brooklyn rather than just a place to crash between tourist activities.

A and FayeBed and Breakfast, Inc, Accommodations

Reviews of A and FayeBed and Breakfast, Inc,

• Sian from United Kingdom (10/10)

  Excellent! The B&B is easy to get to from the airport by road and around a 7 minute walk to the nearest Subway station -Church Avenue. Mr Phil and Ms Faye (I call them Mr & Ms out of respect) are such a lovely welcoming couple. Mr Phil is full of wisdom and is a great conversationalist which was really lovely for me because I was alone on this trip so it was nice to have someone to talk to. My room and bathroom were impeccably clean and very, very spacious. I've stayed in many hotels in NYC and none of the rooms/bathrooms were as large as these. I had a fully stocked bathroom with a plethora of full-sized toiletries including make up removal wipes which were a nice touch. I also had lovely robes and towels provided. The free breakfast was delicious every day and made fresh for me when I came down to eat each morning. I ate alone most days and the grand dining table was laid out so beautifully for me every day, I felt like a Queen! On my last day I was joined by a couple of other people for breakfast and we were treated to a traditional Trinidadian breakfast and Mr Phil playing the steel pan while we ate. I had an amazing stay and I felt very comfortable especially as a solo Black woman. I highly recommend A & Faye Bed and Breakfast.

• Anthony from United States (10/10)

  Super clean. Friendly hosts

• R from United States (10/10)

  Phil is a good host. The neighborhood is good. I enjoyed our short stay in his home. I would recommend.

• Seto from United States (10/10)

  I loved the location near Prospect Park and the subway. It was nice to stay in a neighborhood also. The BnB was very comfortable and the hosts made it easy to come and go.

• Alexis from Canada (10/10)

  This was such beautiful, cozy home. The hosts were wonderful, even in our short stay, we felt like family. And we were so happy to be served an authentic Trini breakfast!

• Klaus from Germany (9/10)

  The hosts

• Sarosh from Germany (8/10)

  Great people

• Joe from Australia (10/10)

  Breakfast was very delicious. Pancakes were great.

• Wright from United States (10/10)

  The owners went above and beyond to make us comfortable and helped in a time of need. Greatly appreciated

• Annegret from Germany (10/10)

  Our hosts. They were so kind and helpful
  The amazing breakfast and the interesting atmosphere to sit at one table like a family,and to hear so much interesting facts from the other guests.

Surroundings

Facilities