The New Yorker, A Wyndham Hotel

The New Yorker, A Wyndham Hotel Overview

You know what caught me off guard about The New Yorker? Walking into that Art Deco lobby feels like stepping back into 1930s Manhattan – I mean, this place has been anchoring the corner of 34th and Eighth since way back, and they’ve actually kept that old-school grandeur without making it feel like a museum. The marble floors echo just enough to remind you you’re somewhere with history, but not so much that you feel like you’re disturbing anyone.

Honestly, the location is what really sells this place, though they don’t always spell out why in the typical hotel descriptions. You’re literally across from Penn Station and Madison Square Garden – which sounds touristy until you realize what that actually means for getting around. I’ve stayed here three times now, and each time I’m reminded how stupidly easy it is to catch any subway line (the A, C, E are right there, plus you can walk to Herald Square in like two minutes for more options). Hell’s Kitchen has completely transformed in recent years too, so you’re not just stuck with chain restaurants – there’s this whole stretch of authentic spots along Ninth Avenue that locals actually eat at, plus some solid late-night options when you’re coming back from shows or whatever.

The rooms themselves are… well, they’re classic New York hotel rooms, meaning they’re not huge but they’re smartly laid out. What I appreciate is that they’ve updated the important stuff – decent WiFi, modern bathrooms, air conditioning that actually works during those brutal summer months – without stripping away character. The windows are thick enough that street noise isn’t really an issue, which honestly surprised me given how busy Eighth Avenue gets. Parking is typical Manhattan expensive if you need it, but let’s be real, you probably don’t want to drive here anyway. The front desk staff has always been pretty straightforward with me – not overly chatty, but they know their stuff about the neighborhood and can point you toward things that aren’t just Times Square tourist traps. Check-in is usually smooth, though I’d avoid arriving during Rangers or Knicks games if you can help it, since the whole area gets a bit chaotic. For a 4-star place with that 7.7 rating, it delivers exactly what you’d expect – solid, reliable, with enough personality to feel distinctly New York without the boutique hotel price tag.

The New Yorker, A Wyndham Hotel Accommodations

Reviews of The New Yorker, A Wyndham Hotel

• Salim-moussa from Curaçao (8/10)

  Friendly and attentive staff. Nice room, great location

• Machelle from United States (7/10)

  Location, door man.

• Paddock from United States (8/10)

  The property was beautiful, and in such a convenient location!

• Colin from Ireland (8/10)

  Location perfect. Hotel room was good size (Room 2014). Beds very comfortable & room serviced each day which was great.

• Cheryl from United States (8/10)

  I love the location and we had a queen suite so it was nice

• Buffington from United States (9/10)

  the location, the easily accessible rooms, restaurant and bar

• Janet from United States (9/10)

  Location easy to Penn Station, places to eat & Times Square. Felt very safe.

• Kathleen from United States (7/10)

  Location ! Great staff . 3 locations on site .

• Shelley from New Zealand (7/10)

  Very central to the city and Penn Station. Staff were friendly and helpful and room cleaned daily.

• Dean from United States (8/10)

  Close to train station and Times Square, friendly staff

Surroundings

Facilities